THIS IS A REVIEW OF ALL
THE EQUIPMENT ONBOARD AFTER A THREE YEARS OF USE.
Galley
SMEV 8000 3 BURNER HOTPLATE:
Rating:8/10
Would we buy again? Yes
We are very glad we made the decision to get a 3 burner hotplate
instead of the 2 burner hotplate and use the three burners at the same
time often. We find the Smev hotplate to be very good and easy to
light. We don't use the ignition switch on the hotplate we bought
a reusable gas lighter. The only thing we find a problem is
cleaning around the control knobs and also the plastic locators that
the plates actually fit into broke off (two have broken off
already). Our concern is that the unit will start to rattle once
the rest of the locators break off.
Update:The
screws holding the tops of the burners in totally corroded away.
They were impossible to get out and had to be redrilled. Better quality
screws could have been used. It makes it very difficult to clean
the jets and the burners.
SMEV OVEN AND GRILL:
Rating: 9/10
Would we buy again? Yes
Our smev oven has got alot of use so far on the trip. Both the
grill and oven are very efficient and heat up reasonably quickly.
At the start we used to use the grill for toast and that took a little
bit longer to do. Instead of this we now use a stainless steel
camping toaster which fits easily over one of our burners on the Smev
hotplate and it works alot better. The oven is easy to clean you
just need to be careful with the controls. When turning on the
grill or oven you need to keep the control pressed in for quite along
time once you have lit the gas, to make sure it doesn't go out.
But I guess this is a good safety
feature so we don't really see it as a problem.
Update:
This is a great unit and we get great use out of the oven. It
hasn't given us any trouble.
VITRIFRIGO FRIDGE, FREEZER
& DANFOSS EXTERNAL COMPRESSOR:
Fridge Rating: 8/10
Freezer Rating: 6/10
Would we buy? Both units are working fine. If we had to replace
them we would probably consider buying a more energy efficient unit.
The fridge has a capacity of 133litres. The freezer has a
capacity of 113litres. Both are separate units and sit beside
each other in our galley. They are very neat units with an
external compressor each. We have placed both compressors through the
bulkhead and sit them outside in the cockpit under the seats. The
fridge works very well and we find we have plenty of
room for what we need. However they provide our biggest
worry so far on the boat in the form of power. According to their
brochures and sales rep the fridge should consum 3.6A at its maximum
and 1.8 at its minimum. The freezer should consume 5.7A at its
maximum and 2.7 at its minimum. We find that both units work
to their maximum all the time therefore chewing up our power.
The freezer is another story. The fan in the compressor went
within the first two months of switching it on. Everything in the
freezer had started to defrost. We had some tuna which we had
caught in a glad bag in the freezer and the blood spilt everywhere and
the stink was just horrendous. We found that the lower
compartment in the freezer was not enclosed and the blood leaked into
the inside of the unit and at this present time are finding it very
difficult to get rid of the smell. As of six months down the
track both cooling fan controllers have died in the fridge and
freezer. Both cooling fan controllers had to be hot wired so they
run 24 hours a day. Otherwise the compressors overheat and will
stop. We have now put in extra ventilation to the compressors
which have made them more efficient but they are still very thirsty on
power.
Update:
We have now found that the control units at the back of
the compressor are very prone to getting moisture in them. They
need to be pulled apart regularly and sprayed to stop them corroding
up. We are on our second or third set of fans for both units
now. They are quite easy to change but if you have these units
you need to carry spares.
Sink:
Rating: 9/10
Would we buy again? Yes
We choose to have a double sink with washboard area. We have no
regrets choosing the double sink over the single one. However in
time we hope to make a top for one of the sinks. Therefore when
its not in use we can place it on and utilise that are more
efficiently.
Update:
We still haven't gotton around to putting a top on one of
the sinks. We usually fill the sink with our plants while on
passage.
Bathrooms:
JABSCO MANUAL TOILET(large bowl):
Older model - Rating: 10/10
New model - Rating: 7/10
Would we buy again? Yes
Initially when deciding on types of toilets we were going to put a
Jabsco manual toilet in one hull and a TMC electric toilet in the other
hull. We purchased both but when it came time to fit them
we found the electric toilet was an awful lot heavier than the manual
so decided to swap the electric for another Jabsco manual toilet.
They were very easy to fit, work very easily and come with very simple
instructions on how to use them. We choose the large bowl not
because we've got big asses but it would be wise just for a comfort
factor as the large bowl isn't that large in fact.
Update:
If you ever need to buy a Jabsco toilet buy the old style Jabsco manual
toilet rather than the newer model. Its far better than the new
on. We have one of each. The new one is noiser to pump and
always leaks water back into the bowl.
Communications:
Barrett 980E HF radio:
Rating: 9/10
Would we buy again? Yes
The Barrett is a compact unit which we sit on shelves down in the port
hull. We use one of our stays as an aerial. The radio was
very easy to fit and its quiet easy to use(even for novices like
us). It comes with quiet good information on various frequencies
to use etc.
We have a few concerns about recieving, transmitting seems to be
always strong but recieving seems to be weak. We are not quiet sure if
this is a fault of ours and the way we set it up or a fault of the
unit.
Update:
Now we have had alot of experience with HF radio's and this HF is as
good as any other HF radio that any other yachtie has onboard. We
have no concerns with recieving.
GME GX 548 VHF FM Marine Transceiver:
Rating: 7/10
Would we buy again? Yes, we would buy the same brand but just a model
with a few more features such as scan.
This unit sits just inside the main door. Its a very simple
unit and works well. We have put our aerial on our targa
therefore restricting our transmission range. The only pain
really is when you need to go to a station other than Channel 16 you
need
to use an up and down button to get to the desired station. There
is no scan button.
Update:
We now have an aerial on the mast and we recieve and transmit very
well.
Navigation:
Interphase Outlook Forward Scanner:
Rating: 8/10
Would we buy again? Yes
This is a good unit. It takes a little while to get used to the
forward scanning part as before we only had the downward scanning
sounders. The only problem that we have with it is the
lighting. There doesn't seem to be an option to increase/decrease
the brightness of the light which makes it a problem when night sailing
as it takes away your night vision.
Update:
This is a great unit and nothing has changed since our previous
comments.
Garmin GPS 152:
Rating: 10/10
Would we buy again? Yes
This is another good unit. Again the only problem we have with
this unit is the fact that it doesn't have a facility to see your
velocity made good which is important for a sailing boat. It only
took us a year but we have now found the VMG function and a whole lot
of other really good settings.
TMQ AP55 Autopilot:
Rating: 10/10
Would we buy again? Absolutely..thats a yes.
Very easy to install. Works very well. Had a problem with
the octopus pump blowing a seal and the immediate reaction from the
manufacturers was that the fact that they didn't install it meant that
it wasn't under warranty anymore. This was very
disappointing. We had to buy a new one for $700 but they did
eventually fix the old one under guarantee. We are very happy
with our autopilot. It works very well in all conditions of
sailing.
Update:
This is an excellent unit.
Still working...just like Guinness in a bottle....Brilliant!
Power:
AirX 400 watt wind generator:
Rating: 8/10
Would we buy again? Yes
The wind generator sits on our targa. It was easy to
install. Compared to other units its noisy. It starts to
generate power at 6knots. From our point of view it would be
better to have a quieter model which starts to generate at lower wind
speeds rather than one that has higher output at higher speeds.
By the time it reaches its peak at 25knots you just want to turn it off
because of the noise and also you always think its going to fall apart
and one of the propellers will fly off and hit you in the back.
Since this we now realise that it is more efficient than alot of other
wind generators that we have come across on other boats. Although
been noisy still it is very efficient and we have got used to the
noise. If we are talking in the cockpit we have the option to
turn it off.
Update:We love the noise because we
know that there is power going into our batteries.
Sharp solar panel NE80EJE 80 watt:
Rating: 9/10
Would we buy again? Yes
We have two 80 watt solar panels installed on our cabin top roof.
They are quiet expensive to buy about $10 per watt. They put out
4 to 5 amps on full output but you need to keep the full sun on them
all the time which means moving the boom around when they're placed on
the roof. Also the corners are very sharp and if you don't do
something about the corners you will be missing a few toes after
awhile. We have now also purchased a 120watt solar panel as we
were finding that we were not quiet keeping up with our power
consumption. As long as we have a bit of sun and a bit of wind
during the day we can just keep up. If we have alot of both we do very
well.
Update:A more efficient way to go
would be a tilting rack on the top of your targa which can move to face
the sun.
Hynautic H20 helm pump:
Rating: 10/10
Would we buy again? Yes
Robust unit fitted well and we never have any problem with it.
Hynautic RAMS:
Rating: 10/10
Easily fitted. Had no problems at all.
Inverter 1000 watt
Rating: 9/10
Would we buy again? No...if we were buying again we would buy a
different unit one that has a charger as well.
It is a 1000 watt pure sine wave inverter. The only problem we
have is
when we want to use a light load it won't except it you have to have a
heavier load on it before it will work correctly.
Update:
We were supplied the wrong remote to turn it off and cannot get another
one to suit the unit. This can be a pain in the arse as its lying
under our settee so you have to lift the settee in order to turn it on
if you don't have the correct load on it.
Deckgear:
Lewmar
Rating: 6/10
Would we buy again? No
We use lewmar winches, blocks, tracks and jammers and have found them
to be very good. We have had no problems with any of them so
far. One of the Lewmar winches the bearings seem to be failing
within less than a year. And the rope jammers have cheap
stainless steel parts in them which rust. We rang Lewmar and told
them about our winch and the rust on our gear and they agreed to
replace everything that we had a problem with. This is great but
the biggest pain is taking deck gear off that you have set with
silicon. This has now been done. The gear looks great we
just hope that it stays that way. Its expensive gear so you
expect good quality.
Update: The new gear they give us the same thing has happened. Rust has
appeared again. 50% of our winches have too much bearing movement. The
jammers are all stil good. Main sheet traveller is a total pain
in the arse as the main pin holding all parts together invariably
slides side ways and ends up jamming the traveller rope. We have
tried locktite it in all to no avail. Once every two weeks we
have to pull it apart and knock the pin through. Very bad design
fault. The agents in Australia have been nothing but helpful and
have gone out of their way to replace the gear we have had a problem
with. However we would not buy it again. What would we go
for? We have no idea. The biggest disapointment is the price of
the gear and the quality we ended up with.
Moonlight Hatches:
Rating: 7/10
Would we buy again? No we would buy hatches that have arms.
As yet we have had no problems with them. They seem to function and
seal well. The only drawback been because they have no arm
holding them up they tend to wave up and down in any sort of breeze and
we can't find any adjustment to tighten the mechanism to stop them
flying open in stronger winds when they are partially up.
Update:
Our hatches have alot of grazes on them from where we walked on
them. This should not happen.
Rigging:
Allyacht Spars
mast:
Product Rating: 10/10
Service Rating: 10/10
The product supplied is very good. We have a small wing section
and a Seldon boom which all appears to be very well made. The
down fall of the unit is trying to extract information from Allyacht
Spars themselves. It appeared that once we had paid our full
amount of money they then became totally disinterested with our queries
and
questions. Quiet possible if we had lived on the East coast it
might have made a bit of difference but we doubt it. Towards the
end of assembling the mast communication became so bad that we had to
make fairly major decisions about the connection from the mast to
cap shroud without any help from them which we felt wasn't very
professional.
We have since had to get a new mast due to a failing in our spectra
lashing. Again we went with Allyacht Spars. This time around we
dealt with Alan Cowardine who was very professional, very helpful and
always returned our calls and answered any queries or concerns that we
had. Their product is still excellent and their service now
matches their product which is how it should be. And we would
recommend them to anyone.
Update:
We have no problems with our mast and rigging. We still get
concerned with the lack of tension in the leeward side but thats purely
catamarans. If we rebuilt we would go for more than a three
stayed mast.
Barracouta Sails:
Rating: 9/10
Would we buy again? Yes, if the price was right!
We got a fully battened fat top main, a screecher, a jib and a
MPS. For one reason or another the only sail which won't have to
go back for adjustment will be the Main sail. We love the sails
and the workmanship seems to be very good and back up service has been
excellent. Neil Tasker has always been very helpful and willing
to accommodate us with any questions and modifications that were
needed. We have also had to get a second set of sails. Main
and Jib. We again went with Barracouta. We had a list of
things that we required to be done differently second time around such
as alot of reinforcing. Neil Tasker is always willing to help out
and modify things if needed. Sometimes his small details need
improving a little.
Update:
After three years our main and jib are in very good condition.
Our screecher which is a code zero is in the 'highlight of its
twilight' and will need to be replace sooner rather than later. The two
longest batten in the main have delaminated where they tapered to go
into the batten holder. We've had to fix this and its an ongoing
problem.
Profurl Furlers:
Rating: 10/10
Would we buy again? Yes
We have two Profurls. One for the Jib and one for the
Screecher. Installation was fairly straight forward and
easy. They both work well. We haven't as yet had any
problems.
Update: No problems good units.
Mechanical:
Yanmar 3GM30FCE 27HP:
Rating: 9/10
Would we buy again? Yes
We have installed two Yanmar 27HP diesel motors. We had a problem
with one of our motors. The fuel pump was gummed up when we first tried
to start it. But Yanmar sent down a engineer to the shed, they
pulled it out, fixed it and put it back within a week. They seem
to give adequate power for what we need and as always are very
reliable. They are a little noisy. They use approx
2 litres an hour at 2500 revs which gives us approx 6 knots.
Update:
We have now done 1300 hours. One motor is starting to smoke a
little bit which is a concern. Its the same one which they
actually fixed at the beginning. Because its two years after
installation there is no warantee. We still think they are a very
reliable motor.
The only real draw back with the Yanmar is the saildrive. You are
supposed to change the oil every 100 hours. If you can't put your
boat on the beach it will become a very expensive hobby. We
change our as close as we can to every 100 hours. But other
yachties we have talked to wait as long as 2000 hours and have had no
problem.
Yanmar should supply you with a tool to open up the oil plug because
you are invariably groping around in the mud to do it.
3 blade feathering Kiwi Props:
Rating: 6/10
Would we buy again? Probably not. However if the price was not a
problem we would go for Gories, but we do like the concept of the
Kiwiprop.
They work very well in forward but appear to have far too much pitch in
reverse and as yet we haven't been able to work out how we can change
the pitch in reverse. We will keep you informed. The motors
will only do 12-1500 revs in reverse before they start to blow alot of
black smoke.
The return springs in both props have since broken. But on
contacting Kiwi Props they sent us two springs straight away. We
as of yet haven't had a chance to install them and our props won't
feather properley. When installed we will keep you updated.
Update:
We have now replaced six sets of springs. We seem to have solved
the problem now by lessening the set up tension in them. We have
had six reverse stoppers shear on one prop and three on the
other. We haven't as yet been given a satisfactory reason as to
why this might happen. If these stoppers shear again we will
drill, tap and replace the originals with an 8mm shaft on them which
hopefully will stop it. All the blades have quite alot of
movement in them now after 1300 hours, so not sure how much longer they
will last. We still have to be careful about stopping as we can't
realistically give many revs in reverse but you get used to that.
We have been assured by the owner of Kiwiprops that ours are the only
props in existence that are having these problems. But that
doesn't help us!
Johnson Waterpump WPS3.4 12V
Rating: 5/10
Would we buy again? No
We have one on each water tank which have worked very well so
far. The only thing we are considering doing is putting an
accumulator in the system to prevent the short cycle times of the
pump. One of these pumps have since stopped working after four
months. When we went to try and take it apart to replace the
impeller every bolt snapped because they were so corroded in the
housing. We replaced it with a Sure Flow Pump and we are waiting
for the other one to give up on us.
As of twelve months the second pump has also died. We have no
Johnson pump onboard now and would never ever buy another. Sure
Flow Pumps seem to work alot better and they are alot cheaper.
Update: Johnson sent us a
refurbished one which we have since reinstalled because the Sure Flow
pumps (and the Johnson pumps) both have pressure limiting switch which
causes the pump to cut in and out as your pressure drops that are not
particularly well protected against moisture. Therefore they
corrode out and die. These switches are available for under $5 at
most washing machine centres and with a bit of fiddling about you can
replace the units within the pump.
Bilgepumps Rule-Mate:
Rating: 5/10
Would we buy again? No
We have six bilge pumps installed. All work well with no problem
at this stage.
We've had one fail with a burnt out motor. Other than that quite
happy with them.
Update:
We've had four now that have died on us and at $170 a unit its an
expensive hobby. We now have gone to TMC with a seperate float
switch to activate it. We will keep you informed with progress.
Simpson-Lawrence Sprint 1500 Vertical
Windlass:
Rating: Unit 2/10
Guarantee backup:10/10 *(see note)
Would we buy again? No, we would go for a larger 'Muir'.
Seems to be powerful enough for our boat. We haven't had any
problem except when the chain to rope splice gets caught at times in
it. Unless you have alot of tension on the rope when its passing
through it doesn't work really well. The arms that feed and
strip the chain and rope of are made of plastic and and under strain
when you have rope on the capston it melts the plastic. Its
absolutley useless to you. We believe that now they have replaced
these parts with stainless and alloy parts which is a better
idea.
We had to send the entire winch back to the importers in Brisbane
because the winch was running out on us. We haven't received it
back yet although they have verbally told us it is all been fixed as
good as new under warantee. This is very good news! We got
the winch back and they had replaced the motor and the anti roll back
gear but within a month the motor had failed. The agents give us
a new motor and we personally replaced all the bearings in the
gearbox. At that point we were still getting intermittent
problems so we replaced the contactor(solenoid) and as of now we seem
to doing ok.
* We've had alot of problems with this winch but every time we have the
agents have always been very quick to respond and have always given us
new parts to replace the ones that failed. We are now onto the
third motor we have replaced all bearings in the whole unit and we are
on our second contactor(solenoid). For the moment all things are
going well but we have completely lost our confidence in this unit and
will keep you posted.
Update:
For a year and a half we haven't had any problems, except for the fact
that the unit dispite been recommended for this size of boat is to
small. There is no way that you could rely on this unit not to
trip out on you if you had to work it hard. Other than that
everything is working fine on it.
Ferrari Trampolines
Rating: 10/10
Would we buy again? Yes
Our tramps are white with small square holes and good space around the
outside for water to flow through. These tramps have been on
three years, exposed to the sun and weather conditions at all
times. They are still in really good condition. They are
very strong and look good. They allow water to flow through them
quite well.
Guarantees/Warranties:
Like everyone else who buys a piece of equipment you should get a
guarantee or warantee with it. When we bought our equipment for
the boat we got guarantees with everything. With alot of the gear
the warantee doesn't start until you actually start using it, but
sometimes with certain goods it starts from the minute you purchase
it. We think after our experience that realistically with alot of
equipment you are better
off (if possible) trying to negotiate a cheaper deal and in which case
you have no waranty/guarantee. When you are five hundred miles
away from a main town and
something breaks down and its still under waranty the invariable
comment is 'send it back to use and we will have a look at it'.
But you can't do without an anchor winch or a water pump for the month
or two or three
that its takes for the coompany to have a look at itl, see what the
problem is and get back to you. You need it replaced pretty
much there and then otherwise its no good to you. So in
cases like this which can be a regular occurence if you are on the move
all the time with a new boat you are better off without a guarantee and
prephaps buying the goods cheaper.
If a piece of equipment breaks down on you and you send it back
because it is still under guarantee. The manufacturer of that
piece of goods in some cases will not honours its guarantee if they
find that you have installed the piece of equipment yourself.
What a pile of bullshit! If you are building your own boat and you were
to get a professional person to install every piece of equipment on
your boat that is under guarantee it would cost you a bloody
fortune! This we found out the hard way with
the Octopusy pump attached to our autopilot. When it died even
though it was still under guarantee they wouldn't honour it as Ric had
installed the piece of equipment and therefore there was no way that it
could have been their problem that the piece of equipment failed...alot
of bullshit really.